There’s nothing like finally getting home after a long commute through cold winter weather. You step inside your front door, take off your coat and snow boots and….are still cold?

If your home is feeling chillier than usual, you may be dealing with a broken or inefficient boiler. If your boiler is old or in need of major repairs, it could mean that a boiler replacement is in your future.

Let us guess: your first thought (besides “Nooooo!”) is, “How much will this cost me?”

A new boiler can be an investment, but it is an essential part of your home that you need in order to function properly. With so much riding on this decision, you probably have all sorts of questions, including:

  • What type of boiler is right for me?
  • Can I DIY my boiler replacement?
  • Can my existing boiler be repaired?

Don’t worry, though, because we have the answers. From boiler replacement cost to the best types of boilers for your home, we have all the information you need to make an informed choice.

Boiler Repair vs. Replacement

boiler replacement cost do i need full replace

Before calling a qualified plumber, it is a good idea to do a little research so that you understand the difference between a boiler repair and a boiler replacement.

A boiler repair is likely to be a more affordable option if it is available. A boiler repair may involve replacing a few parts, but it allows you to keep your existing boiler.

A boiler replacement, on the other hand, involves installing a brand-new boiler system. This can have different levels of difficulty depending on whether or not you switch to a new type of boiler system.

5 Signs You Need a Boiler Replacement

Wondering whether a boiler replacement is right for you or if you can just get by with a repair? The best way to tell is to hire a plumber to perform an inspection. However, if you are noticing any of the following signs, it is a good indicator that your boiler may need to be replaced.

  1. No Heat – It might sound obvious, but if your boiler isn’t heating up, you have a problem on your hands. If the heat levels are low, or you are only getting lukewarm water, it could all be related to a bigger issue.
  2. You’ve Had It Repaired Recently – If your boiler broke down, and you thought it had been fixed by a repair, only to find that it stops working again within a year, there might be an issue too big to be repaired. Frequent problems are a sure sign that it is time for a new boiler.
  3. Your Bills Are Higher – Are your heating bills going up for no obvious reason? It could be because your current boiler is no longer energy efficient. A newer model will help keep your energy costs lower and your home warm all year round.
  4. Leaks – If you notice puddles forming around your boiler, you can bet that you have a leak somewhere. While some leaks are possible to repair, you will likely find that you have more peace of mind with a new boiler.
  5. Bad Smell – If you are smelling a strange odor coming from your boiler, it is important to take action right away. Your boiler could be emitting carbon monoxide, which can be fatal if inhaled in high doses. If you smell a sulphuric odor, open all windows and doors, get outside, and call a professional right away.

How Much Does Boiler Installation And Replacement Cost In 2023?

If the signs above sound familiar to you, you are likely looking at having to purchase and install a brand-new boiler. But how much does a new boiler cost?

In general, homeowners purchasing and installing a new boiler can expect to pay between $9,000-$15,000 for a boiler replacement. These prices typically include the cost of the new boiler itself, as well as labor costs to install it.

Factors That Influence New Boiler Costs

boiler replacement cost assessing best repairs

There are many things that can affect the overall cost of your boiler replacement. Here are some of the top things to be aware of.

Changing Boiler Types

If you are changing boiler styles (for example, going from a gas boiler to an electric one), it will likely cost more than if you buy the same type of boiler as your existing one. Your plumber may have to complete extra labor to ensure that it is set up properly.

Size of Your Home

The size of your home affects the size of your boiler, which can cause prices to go up. If you are looking to purchase a larger boiler to have more hot water or greater heating power, expect to pay more.

Fuel Type

Different fuel types come with different prices. For example, gas boilers are typically more expensive than oil or electric boilers.

Boiler Prices by Type

Looking to know how much each boiler type will cost to replace? We’ve done the research for you!

Electric Boiler Cost

If you are looking for a cost-effective option, you can’t go wrong with an electric boiler! Electric boilers are one of the most affordable options out there, coming in at around $2,500-$5,000 for a replacement.

Oil Boiler Cost

On the other end of the spectrum sits the oil boiler. Oil boilers tend to be the most expensive option, with low-end versions costing around $6,000, all the way up to $10,000 top-of-the-line models.

Gas Boiler Cost

boiler replacement cost fixing gas boiler

Gas, or propane boilers, sit firmly in the middle of the price range. While cheaper versions typically cost the same as a cheap oil boiler, more expensive models will have you paying close to $8,000 for a boiler replacement.

Outdoor Wood Boiler Cost

While you won’t find them in many modern homes, old homes and cabins may still be using wood boilers to help homeowners stay warm. Most plumbers will likely recommend that you upgrade to a more modern style. However, if you are determined to keep it, expect to pay between $5,000-$8,000 for a full replacement.

Combi Boiler Cost

A combination boiler – more frequently referred to as “combi boilers” – is used to heat both water and your home. They are useful space savers as they eliminate the need for a water heater. That being said, they are usually best for smaller homes, as they don’t typically have the power to heat a larger home. For a full replacement, expect to pay between $7,000-$12,000.

Old Boiler Removal and Disposal Cost

When making your budget for your boiler replacement, it is important to also factor in the price of disposal. Most plumbers will not dispose of your old boiler on their own. Instead, you will have to hire a service that specializes in the disposal. This will add roughly $200-$700 to your overall boiler replacement costs.

DIY Cost to Replace a Boiler

You may be tempted to try to save money by learning how to replace a boiler on your own. While this will save you money on labor costs, it might cost you more in the long run. Incorrect installation could lead to water damage and necessary repairs further down the line. That’s why we always recommend hiring a professional.

Get Your Boiler Installation Done Correctly!

Our team at AJ Alberts has been helping the community with a wide range of plumbing needs for years. When it comes to boiler installation, we’ve got you covered. Contact us today for reliable, stress-free plumbing services!